AI DataCenter Law
02 / RESEARCH ATLAS
INDEPENDENT RESEARCH · LAW / ENERGY / INFRASTRUCTUREUS × CHINA   /   FIELDNOTES No. 01

One demand.
Two legal orders.

US electricity regulation divides authority across federal and state institutions. China’s computing-hub policy links national spatial planning with local implementation. Compare how each allocates access, costs and public obligations.

New evidence · 19 October 2026

Newly added to the research atlas. Source publication dates and evidence status appear in each record.

Follow where the law guides.

Research corpus: 6–7 September 2026; approved primary-source additions reviewed 19 October 2026. Each document appears once; its provisions and original record IDs are preserved inside. Shared topics connect the four collections.

1. United States

45 documents

1.1 Federal & regional grid institutions

1.1.1PJM co-location order2 provisions / source records

1.1.1.1 Co-location and transmission-service architecture

Internal source tag US-R001

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Agency final order under FPA § 206
Issued
2025-12-18
Status at corpus cutoff
MODIFIED/SET ASIDE IN PART by 195 FERC ¶ 61,209 (2026); further compliance required, with selected deadlines extended to 2026-11-16; implementation incomplete at the 2026-09-06 cutoff
Pinpoint
193 FERC ¶ 61,217, PP 2–4, 164; Ordering Paragraphs
Recorded legal proposition
FERC found PJM's tariff unjust and unreasonable for lack of clear co-location terms and directed three transmission-service options plus process revisions.
Scope
Commission-jurisdictional transmission and generator-interconnection service; not plenary retail-load siting.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.1.2 Cost allocation for BTM and co-located load

Internal source tag US-R002

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Agency final order under FPA § 206
Issued
2025-12-18
Status at corpus cutoff
MODIFIED/SET ASIDE IN PART by 195 FERC ¶ 61,209 (2026); further compliance required, with selected deadlines extended to 2026-11-16; implementation incomplete at the 2026-09-06 cutoff
Pinpoint
193 FERC ¶ 61,217, PP 2–4, 74–85, 397–414
Recorded legal proposition
FERC found PJM's BTMG rules unjust and unreasonable because planning did not fully account for affected load and costs could shift to other customers.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.2PJM large-load show-cause orderLarge-load transmission integration

Internal source tag US-R003

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Procedural agency order under FPA § 206; preliminary findings only
Issued
2026-06-18
Status at corpus cutoff
Held in abeyance by 196 FERC ¶ 61,129, accession 20260814-3059; response/remedial §205 filing due 2026-11-16; no final replacement tariff at 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
195 FERC ¶ 61,211, PP 1–5, 35–105
Recorded legal proposition
FERC instituted six separate regional proceedings on 2026-06-18; FERC entered docket-specific abeyance orders on 2026-08-14 (196 FERC ¶¶ 61,128–61,133).
Scope
Commission-jurisdictional transmission service and RTO/ISO tariffs.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.3SPP large-load show-cause orderLarge-load transmission integration

Internal source tag US-R004

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Procedural agency order under FPA § 206; preliminary findings only
Issued
2026-06-18
Status at corpus cutoff
Held in abeyance by 196 FERC ¶ 61,128, accession 20260814-3060; response/remedial §205 filing due 2026-11-20; no final replacement tariff at 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
195 FERC ¶ 61,213, PP 1–6, 35–104
Recorded legal proposition
FERC instituted six separate regional proceedings on 2026-06-18; FERC entered docket-specific abeyance orders on 2026-08-14 (196 FERC ¶¶ 61,128–61,133).
Scope
Commission-jurisdictional transmission service and RTO/ISO tariffs.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.4NYISO large-load show-cause orderLarge-load transmission integration

Internal source tag US-R005

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Procedural agency order under FPA § 206; preliminary findings only
Issued
2026-06-18
Status at corpus cutoff
Held in abeyance by 196 FERC ¶ 61,130, accession 20260814-3068; response/remedial §205 filing due 2026-11-16; no final replacement tariff at 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
195 FERC ¶ 61,216, Introduction; Discussion and Briefing Questions
Recorded legal proposition
FERC instituted six separate regional proceedings on 2026-06-18; FERC entered docket-specific abeyance orders on 2026-08-14 (196 FERC ¶¶ 61,128–61,133).
Scope
Commission-jurisdictional transmission service and RTO/ISO tariffs.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.5MISO large-load show-cause orderLarge-load transmission integration

Internal source tag US-R006

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Procedural agency order under FPA § 206; preliminary findings only
Issued
2026-06-18
Status at corpus cutoff
Held in abeyance by 196 FERC ¶ 61,133, accession 20260814-3058; response/remedial §205 filing due 2026-11-16; no final replacement tariff at 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
195 FERC ¶ 61,212, Introduction; Discussion and Briefing Questions
Recorded legal proposition
FERC instituted six separate regional proceedings on 2026-06-18; FERC entered docket-specific abeyance orders on 2026-08-14 (196 FERC ¶¶ 61,128–61,133).
Scope
Commission-jurisdictional transmission service and RTO/ISO tariffs.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.6CAISO large-load show-cause orderLarge-load transmission integration

Internal source tag US-R007

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Procedural agency order under FPA § 206; preliminary findings only
Issued
2026-06-18
Status at corpus cutoff
Held in abeyance by 196 FERC ¶ 61,131, accession 20260814-3061; Six Cities and WAPA rescission relief narrows respondent scope; response/remedial §205 filing due 2026-11-16; no final replacement tariff at 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
195 FERC ¶ 61,214, Introduction; Discussion and Briefing Questions
Recorded legal proposition
FERC instituted six separate regional proceedings on 2026-06-18; FERC entered docket-specific abeyance orders on 2026-08-14 (196 FERC ¶¶ 61,128–61,133).
Scope
Commission-jurisdictional transmission service and RTO/ISO tariffs.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.7ISO-NE large-load show-cause orderLarge-load transmission integration

Internal source tag US-R008

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Procedural agency order under FPA § 206; preliminary findings only
Issued
2026-06-18
Status at corpus cutoff
Held in abeyance by 196 FERC ¶ 61,132, accession 20260814-3056; response/remedial §205 filing due 2026-11-16; no final replacement tariff at 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
195 FERC ¶ 61,215, Introduction; Discussion and Briefing Questions
Recorded legal proposition
FERC instituted six separate regional proceedings on 2026-06-18; FERC entered docket-specific abeyance orders on 2026-08-14 (196 FERC ¶¶ 61,128–61,133).
Scope
Commission-jurisdictional transmission service and RTO/ISO tariffs.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.8Order directing computational-load reliability standardsComputational-load reliability standards

Internal source tag US-R009

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Agency final directive under FPA § 215(d)(5) and (f)
Issued
2026-07-16
Status at corpus cutoff
Effective directive; no computational-load Reliability Standard or registry criterion was yet approved at baseline
Pinpoint
196 FERC ¶ 61,031, PP 1–2, 8–9; Ordering PP (A)–(C)
Recorded legal proposition
FERC ordered NERC to file Phase I computational-load standards and registry changes by 2026-12-31 and a Phase II workplan by 2027-03-01.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.9Executive Order 143182 provisions / source records

1.1.9.1 Strategic status and federal permitting acceleration

Internal source tag US-R010

Authority
President of the United States
Instrument
Presidential executive order
Issued
2025-07-23
Status at corpus cutoff
Current presidential executive order; directives operate subject to applicable law and appropriations and create no enforceable private right
Pinpoint
EO 14318 §§ 1–2, 4–9
Recorded legal proposition
EO 14318 defines covered AI data-center projects above 100 MW and directs coordinated federal permitting, federal-land, and financial-support actions.
Scope
Executive-branch coordination subject to existing law and appropriations.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.9.2 Project qualification and legal limits

Internal source tag US-R011

Authority
President of the United States
Instrument
Presidential executive order
Issued
2025-07-23
Status at corpus cutoff
Current presidential executive order; directives operate subject to applicable law and appropriations and create no enforceable private right
Pinpoint
EO 14318 § 2(a)–(d), §§ 3–6, 10(b)–(c)
Recorded legal proposition
The order states that implementation is subject to applicable law and appropriations and creates no enforceable right or benefit.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.10Large Loads Action PlanReliability implementation status

Internal source tag US-R012

Authority
North American Electric Reliability Corporation
Instrument
Official implementation/program page
Status at corpus cutoff
Ongoing; proposed registry and CLO standards remained in comment at baseline
Pinpoint
Recent Actions; Resources; proposed CLO-001-1, CLO-002-1, CLO-003-1 posting dated 2026-08-19
Recorded legal proposition
The page labels CLO-001-1 through CLO-003-1 and registry changes as proposed/comment materials.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.11Proposed computational-load registry criteria summaryComputational-load registry criteria

Internal source tag US-R013

Authority
North American Electric Reliability Corporation
Instrument
Proposal / consultation material
Issued
2026-04-01
Status at corpus cutoff
First-round proposal; not approved or enforceable; second-round comment remained open at baseline
Pinpoint
Proposal summary pp. 1–3; proposed Appendix 5B changes
Recorded legal proposition
NERC proposed new computational-load entity registration architecture and expressly stated related standards were under development.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.12Computational-load standards development authorizationComputational-load standards development

Internal source tag US-R014

Authority
North American Electric Reliability Corporation
Instrument
Standards-development authorization / proposal
Issued
2026-05-14
Status at corpus cutoff
Drafting authorized; no CLO standard effective at baseline
Pinpoint
Standards Committee Action Without a Meeting, Project 2026-02, pp. 1–4
Recorded legal proposition
NERC's Standards Committee authorized drafting new or modified standards for computational-load integration.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.13NERC announcement of the CEO letter on large-load actionsLegal-status verification

Internal source tag US-R015

Authority
North American Electric Reliability Corporation
Instrument
Official institutional communication
Issued
2026-08-18
Status at corpus cutoff
Current status update; not a Reliability Standard
Pinpoint
NERC Newsroom release dated 2026-08-18
Recorded legal proposition
NERC's CEO letter confirmed parallel work on computational-load registry criteria and proposed standards following the July FERC order.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.142026 draft National Transmission Needs StudyTransmission and equipment bottlenecks

Internal source tag US-R021

Authority
U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Electricity
Instrument
Draft official study under FPA § 216(a)
Issued
2026-07
Status at corpus cutoff
Draft; public comment/consultation open at baseline
Pinpoint
Executive Summary printed pp. ii–iii (PDF pp. 2–3); I.a How to Use This Study, printed p. 2 (PDF p. 18)
Recorded legal proposition
DOE's draft diagnoses national/regional transmission needs but expressly does not displace planning processes or select solutions.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.1510 U.S.C. § 2921Data-center energy and water efficiency

Internal source tag US-R024

Authority
Congress / Office of the Law Revision Counsel
Instrument
Federal statute
Issued
2021-12-27
Status at corpus cutoff
Current federal statute; binding only within its Department of Defense scope
Pinpoint
10 U.S.C. § 2921(a)(1)(A)–(E), (b)(1)–(2)
Recorded legal proposition
Federal statute requires targets for selected existing Do D centers and standards for new Do D data centers, with a national-security waiver.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.16FERC Order No. 1920 — long-term regional transmission planning and cost allocationLong-term regional transmission planning

Internal source tag US-R027

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Agency final rule under FPA section 206
Issued
2024-05-13
Status at corpus cutoff
FERC Order No. 1920 final rule; subsequently clarified and modified by separately archived Orders 1920-A and 1920-B; compliance and implementation ongoing
Pinpoint
Order 1920 series; explainer: Long-Term Scenarios, Evaluation, Cost Allocation, State Engagement
Recorded legal proposition
Order 1920 reforms long-term regional planning and cost allocation but does not decide an individual data-center service request.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.17DOE emergency order on PJM backup resourcesEmergency use of large-load backup resources

Internal source tag US-R028

Authority
U.S. Department of Energy
Instrument
Temporary emergency order under FPA § 202(c)
Issued
2026-09-01
Status at corpus cutoff
Temporary DOE emergency order under FPA § 202(c); operative at 2026-09-06 baseline and expires 2026-09-08 at 11:59 p.m. Eastern unless modified
Pinpoint
Order No 202-26-41,pp 1-2,6-8; Ordering B-L,especially Dcritical-backupexemption,Icostfilings,Knoncapacity,Lexpiryandcontinuingobligations
Recorded legal proposition
DOE temporarily authorized PJM to call specified/large-load backup resources only as a last resort before or during EEA 3, with reporting, environmental, cost-recovery and non-capacity-resource qualifications.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.18Federal Power Act jurisdiction, rates, adequacy, emergency authority and review6 provisions / source records

1.1.18.1 Federal emergency authority

Internal source tag US-R029

Authority
Congress; Office of the Law Revision Counsel; U.S. Government Publishing Office
Instrument
Federal statute
Issued
1935-08-26
Status at corpus cutoff
Current as verified in OLRC preliminary edition on 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
16 U.S.C. § 824a(c)(1)–(5)
Recorded legal proposition
FPA § 202(c) supplies broad but temporary emergency authority and specific environmental constraints.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.18.2 Administrative rehearing and judicial review

Internal source tag US-R030

Authority
Congress; Office of the Law Revision Counsel; U.S. Government Publishing Office
Instrument
Federal statute
Issued
1935-08-26
Status at corpus cutoff
Current as verified in OLRC preliminary edition on 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
16 U.S.C. § 825l(a)-(c)
Recorded legal proposition
FPA § 313 structures rehearing and judicial review for Commission orders; its text does not itself establish the procedure for a Secretary-issued § 202(c) order.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.18.3 Jurisdiction and duty-to-serve allocation

Internal source tag US-R101

Authority
Congress; Office of the Law Revision Counsel; U.S. Government Publishing Office
Instrument
Federal statute
Issued
1935-08-26
Status at corpus cutoff
Current as verified in OLRC preliminary edition on 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
FPA §201(a), (b)(1); 16 U.S.C. §824(a), (b)(1)
Recorded legal proposition
Section 201 expressly confines FERC to matters not subject to state regulation and reserves retail/local-distribution functions.
Scope
Federal regulation covers interstate transmission and wholesale sales but not other sales, local distribution, generation facilities, or intrastate transmission except specifically provided.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.18.4 Rate filing and nondiscrimination

Internal source tag US-R102

Authority
Congress; Office of the Law Revision Counsel; U.S. Government Publishing Office
Instrument
Federal statute
Issued
1935-08-26
Status at corpus cutoff
Current as verified in OLRC preliminary edition on 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
FPA §205(a)-(d); 16 U.S.C. §824d(a)-(d)
Recorded legal proposition
Jurisdictional rates and related practices must be just and reasonable and not unduly preferential; public utilities must file tariffs/contracts and normally give 60 days' notice of changes.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.18.5 Tariff correction and status discipline

Internal source tag US-R103

Authority
Congress; Office of the Law Revision Counsel; U.S. Government Publishing Office
Instrument
Federal statute
Issued
1935-08-26
Status at corpus cutoff
Current as verified in OLRC preliminary edition on 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
FPA §206(a)-(b); 16 U.S.C. §824e(a)-(b)
Recorded legal proposition
After complaint or own-motion proceeding, hearing, and an unjust/unreasonable finding, FERC determines and fixes the just-and-reasonable replacement; refund timing is separately bounded.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.18.6 Adequate interstate service

Internal source tag US-R104

Authority
Congress; Office of the Law Revision Counsel; U.S. Government Publishing Office
Instrument
Federal statute
Issued
1935-08-26
Status at corpus cutoff
Current as verified in OLRC preliminary edition on 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
FPA §207; 16 U.S.C. §824f
Recorded legal proposition
Section 207 is a state-commission-triggered interstate-service remedy, not a general retail applicant entitlement.
Scope
FERC may not compel enlargement of generation or a sale/exchange that impairs the utility's ability to serve its customers.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.19DOE section 403 direction and attached proposed large-load ANOPRProposed national large-load interconnection framework

Internal source tag US-R105

Authority
Secretary of Energy
Instrument
DOE section 403 direction and attached proposed ANOPR; substantive reforms non-final
Issued
2025-10-23
Status at corpus cutoff
DOE proposal docketed in RM26-4; FERC separately invited comments on 2025-10-27 (US-S116); no final nationwide rule or effective federal threshold at 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
DOE letter pp.1–2; attached proposed ANOPR PP1–2, 13–29 (PDF pp.3, 10–14); FERC notice pp.1–2
Recorded legal proposition
The >20 MW threshold and cost/study concepts are proposals, not a universal operational threshold.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.20Southwest Power Pool, Inc., Order Accepting Tariff Revisions Subject to ConditionReliability / flexibility and large-load market access

Internal source tag US-R201

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Binding FERC tariff order under Federal Power Act section 205
Issued
2026-01-14
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE effective 2026-01-15; ministerial compliance accepted 2026-03-09
Pinpoint
pp. 5-10, 25-31; proposed Tariff Attachment BA §§ 2.1.3.3-.5, 2.2.4 and Attachment AE § 2.22
Recorded legal proposition
HILL status covers a new or increased commercial/industrial load at a single site of at least 10 MW at 69 kV or below, or at least 50 MW above 69 kV. Each request receives enhanced study; the HDPS requires a $10,000 nonrefundable fee and $100,000 deposit, plus $200,000 if an EMT study is needed, and has a 90-day target. Ongoing requirements include real-time telemetry, remote disconnect capability, a 20 MW/minute ramp ceiling unless directed otherwise, customer-funded PMU or similar equipment, and ride-through obligations.
Evidence limit
FERC accepted the architecture but required ministerial corrections; the order does not establish a national large-load standard and does not prove performance outcomes.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.21Southwest Power Pool, Inc., Order Accepting CHILLS Tariff Revisions Subject to ConditionMarket access / adequacy / flexibility

Internal source tag US-R202

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Binding FERC tariff order under Federal Power Act section 205
Issued
2026-06-05
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE effective 2026-07-01 subject to condition; compliance filed 2026-07-06 in ER26-1323-002; disposition of that compliance filing NOT_FOUND
Pinpoint
pp. 4-8, 34-45; proposed Tariff Part VII § 44.1, § 47.6, § 48 and Schedule 15
Recorded legal proposition
CHILLS is an as-available, nonfirm bridge for HILL load awaiting designated resources or network upgrades, with a one-year minimum and seven-year maximum. Firm service has priority; CHILLS shares priority with monthly nonfirm point-to-point service and may not be resold, redirected, reassigned, or transferred. Start may be extended once for up to one year with a nonrefundable annual reservation fee; scarce capacity may be released unless the original customer pays the CHILLS transmission rate. Separate telemetry/metering and extensive curtailment obligations apply.
Evidence limit
The June order was conditionally accepted and the July 6 compliance filing remained without a located disposition at the cutoff; a separate FERC section 206 show-cause proceeding also remained open.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.22Guides for the Use of Environmental Marketing ClaimsGreen authenticity

Internal source tag US-R203

Authority
Federal Trade Commission
Instrument
Nonbinding FTC interpretive guides; deceptive claims may be challenged under FTC Act section 5 with proof of deception
Issued
2012-10-11
Status at corpus cutoff
CURRENT interpretive guides; separate review proceeding does not itself amend them
Pinpoint
16 C.F.R. §§ 260.1(a), (c), 260.15(a)-(d), Examples 1-5; PDF pp. 1-2, 31-34
Recorded legal proposition
Unqualified renewable-energy claims may be deceptive where fossil energy is used unless matched with renewable energy certificates; a marketer that sells all RECs for onsite generation cannot also claim to use that renewable energy. The guidance applies to services and business-to-business marketing.
Evidence limit
The Guides are not independently binding law and do not create a mandatory national certificate registry, geographic-deliverability rule, or hourly-matching standard.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.23Generation Attribute Tracking System Operating RulesGreen authenticity / certificate lifecycle

Internal source tag US-R204

Authority
PJM Environmental Information Services
Instrument
Contractually incorporated registry rules, not legislation or an agency regulation
Issued
2024-01-26
Status at corpus cutoff
CURRENT private-registry rules
Pinpoint
Revision 12 cover(PDFp 1); Introduction(PDFpp 6-7),Definitions(PDFpp 8-17); §§10-11; §12.5; §13.2; §14. Printedpage numbers are 5 lessthan PDFpage numbers.
Recorded legal proposition
GATS creates one uniquely identified certificate for each MWh, records transfers, removes certificates from circulation through holder-initiated or automatic retirement, and uses unsettled certificates in a residual-mix process. Retail LSE certificate obligations for a calendar year may be satisfied only with certificates associated with energy generated in that year.
Evidence limit
GATS is a regional contract-based registry rather than a national regulation. Applicable state program rules determine eligibility and deliverability; a GATS certificate is not by itself proof of hourly physical matching or project additionality.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.24PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., Order Rejecting Amended Interconnection Service AgreementCo-location filing genealogy and legal-status counterexample

Internal source tag US-R205

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Binding FERC order on the specific section 205 filing
Issued
2024-11-01
Status at corpus cutoff
REJECTED filing; later generic PJM framework proceedings must be analyzed separately
Pinpoint
189 FERC ¶ 61,078, Substantive Matters, PDF pp. 39-42
Recorded legal proposition
FERC rejected the amended Susquehanna ISA because PJM did not meet the high burden to show that the nonconforming provisions were necessary for project-specific reliability concerns, novel legal issues or other unique factors. Reliance on generally applicable, non-tariff PJM Guidance undermined the claimed uniqueness.
Evidence limit
FERC expressly made no determination on whether the PJM Guidance was just and reasonable and declined to decide other unresolved merits. The holding was filing-specific, not a categorical prohibition on co-location.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.25PJM Interconnection, L.L.C., Order Addressing Arguments Raised on Rehearing and CompliancePJM co-location transmission-service framework

Internal source tag US-R206

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Binding FERC rehearing/compliance order under Federal Power Act section 206
Issued
2026-06-18
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE as modified/set aside in part; further compliance required; deadlines for directives in PP 91, 370-374, 482 and 541 and the transmission-owner directives were extended to 2026-11-16
Pinpoint
195 FERC ¶ 61,209, PDF pp. 3-4, 24, 200-208, 236-245 and 256-258; see US-S210, pp. 2-4, for extension
Recorded legal proposition
The June 2026 order modified/set aside portions of the December 2025 order, resolved parts of the compliance record and required more compliance; selected directives were later extended to November 16, 2026.
Evidence limit
FERC's August 18 notice,published August 21,confirms PJM filed ER26-1479-002 on August 17,accession 20260817-5195,requested October 17 effective,and September 8 comments. Theactualfilingtermsandanyacceptance/effectivenessremainunverified; selectedotherdirectivesremaindue November 16. No acceptedenergizationright inferredfromfilingnotice.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.26DOE's Use of Federal Power Act Emergency AuthorityEmergency-order correspondence procedure

Internal source tag US-R304

Authority
U.S. Department of Energy
Instrument
Official agency webpage / nonbinding correspondence guidance
Issued
2012-05-01
Status at corpus cutoff
Current DOE institutional guidance at the 2026-09-06 baseline; nonbinding and not a formal docket or rehearing rule
Pinpoint
Two correspondence-procedure paragraphs immediately before the issued-orders list
Recorded legal proposition
Current DOE guidance separates correspondence receipt from adjudicatory status and preserves the Secretary's ability to act on an application or without one.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.27Cooling Water Efficiency Opportunities for Federal Data CentersCorrect technical interpretation of a legally used efficiency metric

Internal source tag US-R450

Authority
U.S. Department of Energy, Federal Energy Management Program
Instrument
Nonbinding technical guidance; metric definition, not an operative duty
Status at corpus cutoff
Official guidance available at verification; only stable PUE definition relied upon
Pinpoint
Low-Cost/No-Cost Water-Saving Opportunities at Existing Data Centers: first two paragraphs and PUE equation
Recorded legal proposition
DOE FEMP defines PUE as total annual facility energy use divided by annual IT-equipment energy use. The numerator includes IT energy; overhead divided by IT energy is not PUE.
Evidence limit
This guidance is not the full GB40879 standard and cannot repair missing mandatory Chinese technical clauses.
Corpus review
Adds direct primary technical proof for the corrected memo definition, without relabeling guidance as law.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.28Level 3 Computational Load AlertComputational-load reliability alert

Internal source tag US-R402

Authority
North American Electric Reliability Corporation
Instrument
Institutional alert. Rule 810 acknowledgment and reporting are mandatory; the substantive Essential Actions are not mandatory Reliability Standards.
Issued
2026-05-04
Status at corpus cutoff
Issued May 4, 2026. Acknowledgment was due May 11 and reporting August 3. Substantive actions are voluntary; new CLO standards remain under development.
Pinpoint
Instructions, PDF pages 2–3.
Recorded legal proposition
The Level 3 alert has mandatory response obligations but does not make its substantive Essential Actions mandatory Reliability Standards.
Evidence limit
The alert does not establish individual entity compliance or final CLO standards.
Corpus review
QA-US-06: the mixed-effect distinction was independently verified.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.29Notice of PJM partial co-location compliance filingPJM co-location compliance procedural status

Internal source tag US-R403

Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Instrument
Official procedural notice; it is not approval of tariff terms.
Issued
2026-08-18
Status at corpus cutoff
PJM filed August 17; publication was August 21; comments were due September 8. The requested October 17 effective date was not accepted by this notice.
Pinpoint
PDF page 4, ER26-1479-002 entry.
Recorded legal proposition
The FERC notice confirms actual receipt and notice of PJM’s partial-compliance filing following the June 18 rehearing order; it does not accept the filing.
Evidence limit
The actual filing terms, protests and disposition remain unverified.
Corpus review
QA-US-09 closed the existence gap without overclaiming effectiveness.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.1.30NEWFERC: PJM Large Load Registry accepted; IRAS and BYONC rejectedFederal agency tariff order

Which large-load requirements can an RTO impose without displacing state retail-service jurisdiction?

Internal source tag US-R501

Issued / announced
2026-10-09
Evidence status
FINAL ORDER · Registry and Large Load definition accepted effective 2026-10-12; IRAS/BYONC/VRR exclusion rejected; compliance filing required
Authority
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission
Order / docket
197 FERC ¶ 61,019 · ER26-3515-000
Accepted
50 MW single-site Large Load definition and Large Load Registry; effective 2026-10-12
Rejected
Interim Resource Adequacy Service (IRAS), Bring Your Own New Capacity (BYONC) scheme and related capacity-market treatment
Legal boundary
The rejected provisions are not operative tariff rules; Rosner concurrence cautions against involuntary curtailment ahead of voluntary demand response
Next procedural step
PJM compliance filing directed within 30 days; later compliance requires separate verification
Evidence
Official FERC eLibrary document metadata; official commissioner concurrence. Full order pinpoint should be checked before provision-level quotation

Source record: approved research update · 2026-10-19 · primary/official source; original 2026-09 Excel corpus preserved

1.2 Georgia

1.2.1Georgia Public Service Commission Compliance Order Approving Tariff Revision and Large-Load Contract Framework2 provisions / source records

1.2.1.1 Large-load contract and cost protection

Internal source tag US-R022

Authority
Georgia Public Service Commission
Instrument
Binding state utility-commission order approving compliance tariffs and prescribing contract review safeguards
Issued
2025-04-17
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE; motions for reconsideration do not stay the order absent Commission action
Pinpoint
Compliance Order pp. 1-5
Recorded legal proposition
For customers at or above the 100 MW aggregate threshold, contract minimum-bill, early-termination, and collateral terms must apply the Commission-approved framework; tariff rates may increase while a contractual minimum bill does not automatically change; Staff may object if an actual contractual amount or language inadequately protects other customers.
Evidence limit
Public order establishes review framework, not every contract-specific minimum bill, collateral amount or duration; realized protection remains unproven.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.2.1.2 Procedure and implementation transparency

Internal source tag US-R023

Authority
Georgia Public Service Commission
Instrument
Binding state utility-commission order approving compliance tariffs and prescribing contract review safeguards
Issued
2025-04-17
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE; motions for reconsideration do not stay the order absent Commission action
Pinpoint
Compliance Order pp. 3-5
Recorded legal proposition
Each contract for a new customer with an expected aggregate load of 100 MW or more must be filed at least 30 days before execution. Staff may object within 30 days; absent objection it is deemed approved. If Staff objects, it is deemed approved if the Commission takes no action within 30 days after Staff files its objection. Executed contracts remain filing obligations, and Georgia Power must update minimum-bill model inputs annually.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.3 Ohio

1.3.1AEP Ohio data-center application and tariff implementation guidanceReadiness, study, and queue discipline

Internal source tag US-R016

Authority
AEP Ohio
Instrument
Official utility application and implementation guidance; subordinate to approved tariff
Status at corpus cutoff
Current implementation guidance captured 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
AEP official portal, Mandatory Process ¶¶1–4 and Load Study Fees table (archived HTML lines 3376–3415); threshold cross-check in current Schedule DCT, PDF pp. 113–114, 1st Revised Sheets 223-1–223-2
Recorded legal proposition
After study/service plan, LOA and ESA must be signed within 60 days or the applicant forfeits its place.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.3.2Operative AEP Ohio Data Center Tariff3 provisions / source records

1.3.2.1 Long-term commitment and stranded-cost protection

Internal source tag US-R017

Authority
Ohio Power Company d/b/a AEP Ohio; tariff filed pursuant to Public Utilities Commission of Ohio orders
Instrument
Commission-approved operative utility tariff
Issued
2026-08-28
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE in the official September 2026 tariff book at the 2026-09-06 cutoff
Pinpoint
P.U.C.O. No. 22, Schedule DCT, Sheet Nos. 223-1 through 223-8 (PDF pp. 113-120), especially Sheets 223-4 through 223-7
Recorded legal proposition
The operative August 28, 2026 Schedule DCT combines a ramped contract capacity, minimum billed demand, a ramp-plus-eight-year initial term, credit-conditioned collateral, and a 36-month exit payment after the fifth post-ramp year.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.3.2.2 Behind-the-meter generation and contract capacity

Internal source tag US-R018

Authority
Ohio Power Company d/b/a AEP Ohio; tariff filed pursuant to Public Utilities Commission of Ohio orders
Instrument
Commission-approved operative utility tariff
Issued
2026-08-28
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE in the official September 2026 tariff book at the 2026-09-06 cutoff
Pinpoint
P.U.C.O. No. 22, Schedule DCT, Sheet Nos. 223-7 and 223-8 (PDF pp. 119-120)
Recorded legal proposition
Schedule DCT does not treat onsite generation as a free reduction of grid responsibility: netting Contract Capacity requires an instantaneous matching load-curtailment capability.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.3.2.3 Generation procurement and service-election readiness

Internal source tag US-R038

Authority
Ohio Power Company d/b/a AEP Ohio; tariff filed pursuant to Public Utilities Commission of Ohio orders
Instrument
Commission-approved operative utility tariff
Issued
2026-08-28
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE in the official September 2026 tariff book at the 2026-09-06 cutoff
Pinpoint
Schedule DCT, 1 st Revised Sheet 223-5; September 2026 tariff book PDF p.117
Recorded legal proposition
The interim procedures require 180 days advance notice for New Load initially electing SSO and CRES customers switching/returning to SSO. The customer pays separate procurement costs. If required notice is absent and AEP must serve the customer, customer-funded security and PJM spot energy purchases apply until separate procurement is possible. The final sentence expressly disclaims AEP capacity procurement for load returning to SSO; its wording does not expressly extend that exclusion to initial New Load.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.4 Texas

1.4.1Texas S.B. 6 large-load statute3 provisions / source records

1.4.1.1 Large-load classification, maturity, and study

Internal source tag US-R031

Authority
Texas Legislature
Instrument
State statute
Issued
2025-06-20
Status at corpus cutoff
Current; effective immediately upon gubernatorial approval because recorded votes exceeded two-thirds in each chamber
Pinpoint
S.B. 6 §2, Texas Utilities Code §37.0561(c)-(j)
Recorded legal proposition
Unused study-fee balance is credited toward procurement/interconnection obligations at the same site; it is not categorically nonrefundable.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.4.1.2 Connection cost and cancellation risk

Internal source tag US-R032

Authority
Texas Legislature
Instrument
State statute
Issued
2025-06-20
Status at corpus cutoff
Current; effective immediately upon gubernatorial approval because recorded votes exceeded two-thirds in each chamber
Pinpoint
S.B. 6 §§1, 2, 7; Texas Utilities Code §§35.004(c-1)-(c-2), 37.0561(h)-(j)
Recorded legal proposition
Section 35.004(c-1) applies only to interconnection agreements entered on or after 2025-06-20.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.4.1.3 Emergency curtailment and backup deployment

Internal source tag US-R033

Authority
Texas Legislature
Instrument
State statute
Issued
2025-06-20
Status at corpus cutoff
Current; effective immediately upon gubernatorial approval because recorded votes exceeded two-thirds in each chamber
Pinpoint
S.B. 6 §2, §4; Texas Utilities Code §§37.0561(e), 39.170(a)-(b)
Recorded legal proposition
Texas law converts specified large-load backup/flexibility into an emergency reliability instrument under ordered conditions.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.4.2ERCOT Batch Zero processBatch study and large-load readiness

Internal source tag US-R034

Authority
ERCOT; Public Utility Commission of Texas
Instrument
Approved ERCOT Planning Guide revision
Issued
2026-03-04
Status at corpus cutoff
Approved 2026-06-18; effective 2026-07-11 except §9.6.1(2)-(3); Batch Zero classifications were delayed for gubernatorial audit and issued provisionally/conditionally on 2026-09-03
Pinpoint
PGRR145 §§9, 9.6.1; Governor directive dated 2026-08-03; ERCOT notices M-A080326-01, -03, -04
Recorded legal proposition
Status is conditional implementation, not fully completed and not indefinitely suspended.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.4.3ERCOT Large Load Forecasting CriteriaForecast inclusion and project readiness

Internal source tag US-R106

Authority
Public Utility Commission of Texas
Instrument
Final state administrative rule
Issued
2026-02-09
Status at corpus cutoff
Current; permanent criteria cross-reference proposed §25.194 in pending Project 58481, while §25.370(g)-(h) provides 2026 transition criteria
Pinpoint
16 TAC §25.370(b)(2), (c)-(h); 51 TexReg 1110–1112 (PDF pp.68–70 of adoption issue)
Recorded legal proposition
§25.370 governs forecast inclusion, not by itself a physical interconnection entitlement or energization deadline.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.4.4Governor of Texas data-center audit directiveVerification gate and conditional Batch Zero status

Internal source tag US-R107

Authority
Governor of Texas
Instrument
Executive directive letter
Issued
2026-08-03
Status at corpus cutoff
Directive at baseline; later ERCOT implementation is separately indexed in US-S117–120
Pinpoint
Governor directive pp.1–2; ERCOT notices M-A080326-01, -03, -04
Recorded legal proposition
A claimed August cancellation/postponement must be coded as delay plus conditional resumption, not permanent rejection.
Corpus review
ROOT-04: current provisional-classification claim separately reverified against opened notice04. Search-only historical notices01–03 removed as supporting premises; retained in genealogy solely as unresolved leads.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.4.5Batch Zero Conditional Classification issued to Transmission and/or Distribution Service ProvidersBatch Zero classification dispute routes

Internal source tag US-R039

Authority
Electric Reliability Council of Texas
Instrument
Official regional-system implementation notice
Issued
2026-09-03
Status at corpus cutoff
Current conditional-classification update at cutoff
Pinpoint
M-A080326-04, Long Description paragraphs 2–3
Recorded legal proposition
The September 3 notice identifies differentiated dispute routes; provisional classification is not an unconditional right to interconnect.
Evidence limit
Full underlying ADR rules, dispute form and project-specific outcomes are not established by this notice alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.5 Virginia

1.5.1Data Centers in Virginia2 provisions / source records

1.5.1.1 Generation adequacy and transmission constraints

Internal source tag US-R019

Authority
Virginia Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission
Instrument
Final official legislative study
Issued
2024-12-09
Status at corpus cutoff
Final official legislative study; nonbinding and evidentiary rather than a source of legal duties
Pinpoint
Report 598, pp. ii–v (PDF pp. 5–8), Recommendations pp. x–xi
Recorded legal proposition
JLARC documented legal and physical constraints and proposed legislative options.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.5.1.2 Environmental and community legitimacy

Internal source tag US-R020

Authority
Virginia Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission
Instrument
Final official legislative study
Issued
2024-12-09
Status at corpus cutoff
Final official legislative study; nonbinding and evidentiary rather than a source of legal duties
Pinpoint
Report 598, pp. vi–viii (PDF pp. 9–11)
Recorded legal proposition
The official study reports aggregate and localized environmental findings and recommends stronger information and local tools.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.5.2Va. Code § 10.1-1322.6 — Data-center engine-generator permit limitsAir permitting for backup generation

Internal source tag US-R025

Authority
Virginia General Assembly
Instrument
State statute
Issued
Not established in the source record.
Status at corpus cutoff
Current Virginia statute for covered permit applications submitted on or after 2026-07-01
Pinpoint
Va. Code § 10.1-1322.6(A)-(C)
Recorded legal proposition
Virginia conditions covered new data-center generator permits on Tier 4-equivalent limits while preserving stricter law.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.5.3Va. Code § 15.2-2209.5Local siting and community assessment

Internal source tag US-R026

Authority
Virginia General Assembly
Instrument
State statute
Issued
Not established in the source record.
Status at corpus cutoff
Current Virginia statute; 2026 cc. 567, 568
Pinpoint
Va. Code § 15.2-2209.5(A)-(G)
Recorded legal proposition
Virginia requires a defined sound assessment and utility infrastructure information before specified local approvals for ≥100 MW facilities.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.5.4Virginia SCC Final Order adopting large-load Rate Schedule GS-53 provisions / source records

1.5.4.1 Large-load rate classification

Internal source tag US-R035

Authority
Virginia State Corporation Commission
Instrument
Binding final state utility-commission order
Issued
2025-11-25
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE; principal GS-5 obligations effective 2027-01-01
Pinpoint
Virginia SCC Final Order pp.22–26
Recorded legal proposition
The final order creates GS-5 for 2027 with covered-customer and cohort distinctions; minimum demand billing is 85% distribution,85% transmission and 60% generation, subject to the adopted provisions.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.5.4.2 Long-term commitment and collateral

Internal source tag US-R036

Authority
Virginia State Corporation Commission
Instrument
Binding final state utility-commission order
Issued
2025-11-25
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE; principal GS-5 obligations effective 2027-01-01
Pinpoint
Final Order pp. 23-26
Recorded legal proposition
GS-5 begins January 1, 2027 for customers with measured or contracted demand of at least 25 MW on a contiguous site and measured or expected load factor of at least 75%. Contract and collateral provisions apply to customers taking initial service AND signing an ESA on or after January 1, 2027. The term is 14 years including an optional ramp of no more than four years with at least 20% annual ramp. Minimum charges are 85% distribution, 85% transmission and 60% generation, with PJM capacity expense excluded from the generation floor and the specified legacy/maintenance exemptions. Exit during the term entails outstanding minimum charges for the remaining term, subject to reassignment. Starting collateral is $1.5 million/MW, with up to 70% credit reduction and annual release of one-fourteenth.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.5.4.3 Procedure and future interconnection review

Internal source tag US-R037

Authority
Virginia State Corporation Commission
Instrument
Binding final state utility-commission order
Issued
2025-11-25
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE; principal GS-5 obligations effective 2027-01-01
Pinpoint
Final Order / SCC fact sheet: interconnection-process filing and alternative allocation
Recorded legal proposition
The SCC coupled immediate rate findings with mandated future interconnection/cost-allocation review.
Evidence limit
New CIAC tariff approval, projectactualcost recovery, appellateassignments/disposition andstay status are not established by the July 31 orderand August 28 notice alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.5.5Amazon Data Services IAD-870 Campus Stationary Source Permit to Construct and OperateAir permitting for data-center generation

Internal source tag US-R301

Authority
Virginia Department of Environmental Quality, Northern Regional Office
Instrument
Project-specific minor-new-source-review air permit
Issued
2026-03-26
Status at corpus cutoff
Final legally enforceable construction-and-operation permit
Pinpoint
Transmittal pp. 1-2; permit equipment list and Conditions 2-4, 14-24, 27-28
Recorded legal proposition
Virginia's air gate operates through detailed, enforceable site-specific conditions rather than the statutory Tier-4 phrase alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.5.6Rider T1 Final OrderDirect-connect cost allocation and residual network cost risk

Internal source tag US-R401

Authority
Virginia State Corporation Commission
Instrument
Final state utility commission order approving Rider T1 and directing a future tariff filing.
Issued
2026-07-31
Status at corpus cutoff
Adopted. Rider T1 became effective September 1, 2026. This order did not approve the new CIAC policy tariff. Microsoft filed a notice of appeal on August 28.
Pinpoint
Printed pages 6–7 and 11–17.
Recorded legal proposition
The July 31 final order approves amended 12-CP Rider T1 allocation and directs a prospective, net-of-transmission-revenue, direct-connect CIAC proposal. The actual new CIAC tariff is not approved by this order, and residual higher-order network costs remain unresolved.
Evidence limit
The actual line-extension tariff, later approval, project outcomes, appellate assignments, disposition and stay status are not established.
Corpus review
QA-US-02: source original was read through the official web service but is not locally archived.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

1.5.7Microsoft notice of appeal from July 31 Rider T1 final orderAppellate review of Virginia Rider T1 order

Internal source tag US-R404

Authority
Microsoft Corporation; filed with Virginia State Corporation Commission
Instrument
Filed party pleading; not a judicial decision or stay.
Issued
2026-08-28
Status at corpus cutoff
Microsoft filed a notice of appeal to the Virginia Supreme Court on August 28. Merits, assignments of error and any stay are not established by this notice.
Pinpoint
PDF page 1 filing stamp and page 3 notice.
Recorded legal proposition
Microsoft filed a notice of appeal on August 28, 2026 from the July 31 PUR-2026-00056 final order.
Evidence limit
The notice contains no assignments of error, stay order or appellate disposition. It cannot establish reversal or an automatic stay.
Corpus review
QA-US-02 procedural posture verified from the actual filed pleading.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2. China

42 documents

2.1 National — departmental rules

2.1.1Classified Management Catalog for Environmental Impact Assessment of Construction Projects (2021 Edition)EIA classification

Internal source tag CN-R306

Authority
Ministry of Ecology and Environment
Instrument
Departmental rule/catalog
Issued
2020-11-30
Status at corpus cutoff
Current at baseline; a revised 2026 catalog had received in-principle approval on 2026-09-03 but was not yet promulgated
Pinpoint
Arts. 4-5; component-specific catalog items
Recorded legal proposition
China's national EIA gate is catalog/component based rather than a uniform full-EIA mandate for every facility labeled a data center.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.1.2Measures for Public Participation in Environmental Impact AssessmentEIA public participation

Internal source tag CN-R307

Authority
Ministry of Ecology and Environment
Instrument
Departmental rule
Issued
2018-07-16
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
MEE Order4 arts.2,9–11,14–27,30–31,34
Recorded legal proposition
The national participation rule's Article 2 turns on the legally required EIA document type, not merely the label 'data center'.
Corpus review
P2: staged disclosure is in9–11 and22–27; art31 allows scoped industrial-park simplification, while art30 excludes unrelated land/property/employment claims from this EIA participation channel.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2 National — laws, rules and standards

2.2.1Energy Law of the People's Republic of China5 provisions / source records

2.2.1.1 Strategic competence, planning, and access

Internal source tag CN-R001

Authority
National People's Congress Standing Committee
Instrument
National law
Issued
2024-11-08
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Energy Law arts. 11–20, 31, 36–37
Recorded legal proposition
The Energy Law establishes multi-level planning, power-system coordination, and a general reliable-supply duty subject to legal/contractual grounds.
Scope
Framework national law requiring subordinate rules, plans, market instruments, and local implementation.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.1.2 Strategic energy governance and market organization

Internal source tag CN-R002

Authority
National People's Congress Standing Committee
Instrument
National law
Issued
2024-11-08
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Energy Law arts. 6–7, 15–20, 40–45
Recorded legal proposition
The Energy Law establishes national energy planning and unified-market institutions and encourages, rather than mandates, long-term agreements for energy production/supply/sales, transmission-network construction and use.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.1.3 Green-energy obligation and measurement

Internal source tag CN-R003

Authority
National People's Congress Standing Committee
Instrument
National law
Issued
2024-11-08
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Energy Law arts. 23, 34–35
Recorded legal proposition
The Energy Law supplies statutory foundations for renewable-consumption duties, GECs, metering, and user demand response.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.1.4 Energy emergency and resilience

Internal source tag CN-R004

Authority
National People's Congress Standing Committee
Instrument
National law
Issued
2024-11-08
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Energy Law arts. 52–55; art. 73 (liability)
Recorded legal proposition
The Energy Law requires qualifying large users to prepare emergency plans (art.53), authorizes listed emergency measures (art.54), and requires compliance with lawful unified command with compensation according to law (art.55). It does not classify all data centers as protected critical load.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.1.5 Network access disputes and statutory enforcement

Internal source tag CN-R037

Authority
National People's Congress Standing Committee
Instrument
National law
Issued
2024-11-08
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Energy Law arts.43,67,70–72
Recorded legal proposition
Art.67 permits provincial-or-higher energy-authority coordination of network access/use disputes and court proceedings if coordination fails, while also allowing direct court filing. Arts.70–72 provide enforcement consequences for specified supply, nondiscrimination and information duties.
Evidence limit
No matched project-dispute outcome sample.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.2Basic Rules for Electricity Market Operation2 provisions / source records

2.2.2.1 Electricity-market actors and access

Internal source tag CN-R005

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Departmental rule
Issued
2024-04-25
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Order20 arts.3–8 (members, registration, operations, fair grid access); arts.10–15 (energy, ancillary services, capacity and trading)
Recorded legal proposition
Order20 recognizes electricity users and new entities including storage, VPPs and load aggregators (art.4); establishes registration (art.5); requires fair network opening and regulated transmission/distribution prices (art.7); and distinguishes energy, ancillary-service and capacity transactions (arts.10–13).
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: removed unsupported credit requirement from the proposition attributed solely to Order 20.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.2.2 Market duties and system responsibility

Internal source tag CN-R006

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Departmental rule
Issued
2024-04-25
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Order20 arts.16–22 (market/ancillary-service conditions); arts.23–29 (metering/settlement); arts.30–40 (system security, risk and disclosure)
Recorded legal proposition
Order20 combines market participation with dispatch, security checks, metering/settlement, market-risk controls and disclosure obligations; it does not make bilateral procurement independent of system operation.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.3Basic Rules for Electricity Market RegistrationElectricity-market registration

Internal source tag CN-R007

Authority
National Energy Administration
Instrument
Administrative normative rule
Issued
2024-09-13
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Registration Basic Rules arts.1–7,10–20,25–30,32–45,51
Recorded legal proposition
NEA Rule 76 standardizes market registration categories and procedures nationally.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: registration/change/exit propositions need operative procedural articles rather than arts.1–7 alone. Art.39 supplies a contractual exit pathway, not a universal minimum bill.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.4Power Demand-Side Management Measures (2023)2 provisions / source records

2.2.4.1 Demand response and flexible load

Internal source tag CN-R008

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission and five other departments
Instrument
Administrative normative measure
Issued
2023-09-15
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
DSM Measures arts.12–20; PDF pp.4–7; art.54 (five-year validity)
Recorded legal proposition
The DSM Measures distinguish voluntary response (art.12), a2025 provincial capability target of3%–5% of maximum load (art.14), integration with energy/ancillary/capacity mechanisms (art.16), and market-linked compensation principles (art.19). The target is not evidence of achieved response capacity.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: preserve special >=5% provincial qualification and target-versus-individual-duty distinction.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.4.2 Orderly electricity use and cost principles

Internal source tag CN-R009

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission and five other departments
Instrument
Administrative normative measure
Issued
2023-09-15
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
DSM Measures art.12 and arts.38–41; PDF pp.11–12
Recorded legal proposition
The DSM Measures distinguish voluntary demand response (art.12) from orderly-use administrative/technical control after other balancing measures are insufficient (art.38), then allocate planning/execution roles (arts.39–41).
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.5Power Load Management Measures (2023)2 provisions / source records

2.2.5.1 Load management and controllability

Internal source tag CN-R010

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission; National Energy Administration
Instrument
Administrative normative measure
Issued
2023-09-07
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Load Management Measures arts.3–12,13,23–32,33–36
Recorded legal proposition
Load-management rules separately govern voluntary response agreements, compulsory orderly-use execution and a funded technical-control infrastructure. They allocate some implementation costs between the grid and users rather than assigning all costs to one side.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.5.2 Curtailment priority and implementation

Internal source tag CN-R011

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission; National Energy Administration
Instrument
Administrative normative measure
Issued
2023-09-07
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Load Management Measures arts.15–18,24,26–29,31–32
Recorded legal proposition
The measures prohibit indiscriminate orderly-use restrictions in the name of energy-saving target assessments (art.15), prioritize specified users (art.16), restrict specified noncompliant/inefficient loads (art.17), and distinguish ordinary notice from emergency exceptions (arts.27–29).
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.6Interim Measures for Power Reliability ManagementPower reliability management

Internal source tag CN-R012

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Departmental rule
Issued
2022-04-16
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
NDRC Order 50 arts.2–8,16–31,35–39,45–50
Recorded legal proposition
Order No. 50 provides general reliability-management rules but no data-center-specific technical standard.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: adds materially relevant user/important-user provisions; earlier pinpoint did not cover the user chapter or information reporting.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.7Guiding Opinions on Accelerating Virtual Power PlantsVirtual power plants and aggregated flexibility

Internal source tag CN-R013

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission; National Energy Administration
Instrument
Policy guidance / administrative normative document
Issued
2025-03-25
Status at corpus cutoff
Current; provincial implementation required
Pinpoint
Guidance I; II(1)–(2); IV(5)–(7); V(8)–(11); VI(12)–(13)
Recorded legal proposition
The 2025 guidance sets national VPP development goals and recognizes aggregated adjustable load as system/market resource.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: issuance date is not a separately stated commencement date; market obligations require section V, not I–IV alone.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.8Notice on Orderly Development of Single-User Green-Power Direct Connection3 provisions / source records

2.2.8.1 Single-user green-power direct connection

Internal source tag CN-R014

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission; National Energy Administration
Instrument
Administrative normative policy
Issued
2025-05-21
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE; national single-user framework requiring provincial implementation and project-specific approval/filing
Pinpoint
Notice 650 I(1); II(3)–(6); IV(14); V (provincial implementation)
Recorded legal proposition
Notice 650 establishes a single-user, physically traceable direct-connection pathway with quantitative self-use and renewable-share constraints, not an unrestricted private-wire exemption.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: quantitative and export conditions in II(6) expressly concern grid-connected projects; do not silently equate its pre-2030 wording with Notice1192's new-project-from-2030 wording.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.8.2 Direct-connection cost and reliability responsibility

Internal source tag CN-R015

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission; National Energy Administration
Instrument
Administrative normative policy
Issued
2025-05-21
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE; national single-user framework requiring provincial implementation and project-specific approval/filing
Pinpoint
Notice 650 II(5); III(7)–(11); IV(12)–(14)
Recorded legal proposition
The framework assigns internal balancing and interruption risk to the project while preserving payment for residual public-grid and policy services.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P1: corrected renewable-consumption difficulty mistranslated as general grid difficulty; narrowed storage mandate and cost attribution.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.8.3 Green-claim authenticity

Internal source tag CN-R016

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission; National Energy Administration
Instrument
Administrative normative policy
Issued
2025-05-21
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE; national single-user framework requiring provincial implementation and project-specific approval/filing
Recorded legal proposition
Notice 650 requires an auditable physical interface but makes certificate ownership and transfer a separate legal/accounting layer.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.9Notice on Orderly Development of Multi-User Green-Power Direct Connection2 provisions / source records

2.2.9.1 Multi-user green direct connection and project structure

Internal source tag CN-R017

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission; National Energy Administration
Instrument
Administrative normative policy
Issued
2026-05-14
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE; national multi-user framework requiring provincial implementation and project-specific approval/filing
Pinpoint
Notice 688 I; II(1)–(3); III(4)–(6)
Recorded legal proposition
Notice 688 extends direct connection to multiple independent users and expressly prioritizes computing facilities, but requires one project-level legal and operational interface.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P1: the exclusion is not all grid operators; II(2) identifies public-grid enterprises that operate transmission. Pinpoint corrected to actual section numbering.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.9.2 Multi-user project as system participant

Internal source tag CN-R018

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission; National Energy Administration
Instrument
Administrative normative policy
Issued
2026-05-14
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE; national multi-user framework requiring provincial implementation and project-specific approval/filing
Pinpoint
Notice 688 III(4)–(6); IV(7)–(11); V (implementation)
Recorded legal proposition
The project becomes a market, dispatch, metering and certificate interface; multi-user internal allocation is not equivalent to independent unrestricted retail choice.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P1/P2: source has numbered items1–11, not clauses7–16; corrected curtailment scope, optional initial bidding, storage accounting and optional internal allocation.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.10Implementation Rules for Renewable-Energy Green Electricity Certificates (Trial)2 provisions / source records

2.2.10.1 Green-certificate issuance and title

Internal source tag CN-R019

Authority
National Energy Administration
Instrument
Administrative normative rule
Issued
2025-11-28
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE on issuance; valid for three years
Pinpoint
GEC Rules arts.3,10–17,19–32,37–38,41,43,45
Recorded legal proposition
The implementing rules organize issuance, transfer and retirement. Art.31 introduces same-production/consumption-year retirement claims fromJan1 2026, while the rules as a whole take effect from issuance underart.45.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: added art.17 for tradability,19/41 for five-year retention and43 for duplicate certificates/falsification.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.10.2 Self-use, storage and certificate limitations

Internal source tag CN-R020

Authority
National Energy Administration
Instrument
Administrative normative rule
Issued
2025-11-28
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE on issuance; valid for three years
Pinpoint
GEC Rules arts.17,20,23,25–33,43
Recorded legal proposition
The rules distinguish tradable/non-tradable attributes, storage limitations and retirement scenarios. Annual vintage consistency does not itself establish hourly physical delivery.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: art.33 is required for the stated objection pathway.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.11Notice on GEC issuance for non-public-grid renewable projectsNon-public-grid GEC issuance

Internal source tag CN-R021

Authority
National Energy Administration General Office
Instrument
Administrative implementation notice
Issued
2026-06-05
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Notice 60 §§ 1–4; Attachment steps 1–8
Recorded legal proposition
Notice60 establishes a data-submission and verification pathway for issuing green certificates to renewable generation not directly connected to the public grid, including eligible off-grid, internal-grid and direct-connection projects.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: corrected 'closes an evidentiary pathway,' which suggested restriction rather than creation of a verified issuance route.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.12Special Action Plan for Green and Low-Carbon Development of Data Centers2 provisions / source records

2.2.12.1 National data-center green/low-carbon targets

Internal source tag CN-R022

Authority
NDRC, MIIT, NEA, National Data Administration
Instrument
National policy plan
Issued
2024-07-03
Status at corpus cutoff
Current plan; targets are not self-executing project permits
Pinpoint
Action Plan I; II(1),(2),(4),(5); III(1); PDF pp.1–4
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: the seven-page plan has no target table; replaced generic/inaccurate locator with actual sections and preserved policy-force qualification.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.12.2 Energy-compute coordination

Internal source tag CN-R023

Authority
NDRC, MIIT, NEA, National Data Administration
Instrument
National policy plan
Issued
2024-07-03
Status at corpus cutoff
Current plan; targets are not self-executing project permits
Pinpoint
Action Plan II(1)–(6); III(1)–(3); IV(2)–(3); PDF pp.1–7
Recorded legal proposition
The plan treats data-center efficiency, supply structure, siting, and operational flexibility as an integrated policy problem.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: source-grid-load-storage is not the literal mechanism stated in this plan; the actual text addresses coordinated siting, power-compute joint operation, load adjustment, equipment, monitoring and differentiated management.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.13Implementation Opinions on East Data–West Compute and the National Integrated Computing Network2 provisions / source records

2.2.13.1 Compute geography and national hub concentration

Internal source tag CN-R024

Authority
NDRC, National Data Administration and other departments
Instrument
National policy guidance
Issued
2023-12-25
Status at corpus cutoff
Issued policy guidance; stated end-2025 targets are historical milestones at baseline, not verified outcomes.
Pinpoint
Implementation Opinions §§ I–III, especially items (5), (9), and national-hub targets
Recorded legal proposition
The Opinions use spatial planning and network coordination to move suitable workloads toward energy/resource-rich regions.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: avoid importing an unsupported numerical hub count into this instrument-specific record.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.13.2 Compute-electricity coordination

Internal source tag CN-R025

Authority
NDRC, National Data Administration and other departments
Instrument
National policy guidance
Issued
2023-12-25
Status at corpus cutoff
Issued policy guidance; stated end-2025 targets are historical milestones at baseline, not verified outcomes.
Pinpoint
Implementation Opinions III(9); V(13)–(14)
Recorded legal proposition
The national compute-network policy explicitly coordinates computing deployment with green electricity and grid resources.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: compute-electricity integration is section V, while cross-regional scheduling is III(9); section IV concerns compute/data/algorithms.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.14Action Plan for High-Quality Development of Computing InfrastructureComputing-infrastructure capacity and utilization

Internal source tag CN-R026

Authority
Ministry of Industry and Information Technology and five other departments
Instrument
National policy plan
Issued
2023-10-08
Status at corpus cutoff
Issued policy plan with stated2025 target horizon; no achievement or automatic electricity-user reclassification established.
Pinpoint
Action Plan introduction; I(3); II(1),(5),(6); III; PDF pp.1–3,9–12
Recorded legal proposition
The plan describes computing infrastructure as an important component of new information infrastructure and sets2025 development, green-efficiency and security objectives. It does not by itself reclassify data centers out of ordinary electricity-user status.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: removed unsupported legal-category contrast 'rather than ordinary commercial load' and clarified elapsed target horizon.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.15Maximum allowable values of energy efficiency and energy efficiency grades for data centersMandatory data-center energy efficiency

Internal source tag CN-R027

Authority
State Administration for Market Regulation / Standardization Administration
Instrument
Mandatory national standard
Issued
2021-10-11
Status at corpus cutoff
Current mandatory national standard at the baseline; a revision was under consultation through 2026-09-09 and was not final
Pinpoint
SAMR national-standard metadata: title, mandatory/current status, basic information issue/effective dates and revision link; no technical clauses independently retrieved
Recorded legal proposition
Official SAMR/SAC metadata confirms current mandatory status, issue date 2021-10-11 and effective date 2022-11-01.
Evidence limit
PRIMARY_NOT_RETRIEVED: full technical standard initially unavailable; official metadata only. See G06.
Corpus review
P1 archive correction: original primary archive was a reader shell. Replace with verified SAMR metadata archive. Keep full-text measurement boundaries/grade limits UNKNOWN; no CAPTCHA bypass.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.16Official consultation page for the data-center efficiency-standard revisionRevision of mandatory PUE standard

Internal source tag CN-R028

Authority
Standardization Administration
Instrument
Official consultation notice / standard-development metadata
Issued
2026-07-09
Status at corpus cutoff
Consultation open through 2026-09-09; not effective
Pinpoint
SAMR consultation notice dated 2026-07-09; Plan 20251056-Q-469 project page
Recorded legal proposition
SAMR has a mandatory-standard revision in consultation, but no replacement standard was issued by baseline.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: proposed12-month period must not be stated as an already-fixed legal commencement rule.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.17Technical specification for trusted evaluation of carbon efficiency of computing for data centersCompute-carbon efficiency

Internal source tag CN-R029

Authority
Standardization Administration / Ministry of Ecology and Environment
Instrument
Recommended national-standard development plan
Issued
2026-04-28
Status at corpus cutoff
Planned/drafting; not an issued standard
Pinpoint
SAMR national-standard project 20262489-T-467: scope, stage and 15-month cycle
Recorded legal proposition
SAMR metadata records a recommended national-standard project for trusted evaluation of data-center computing carbon efficiency, including planned definitions, calculation/accounting methods and evaluation procedures. No final formula or technical standard is established by this metadata.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: metadata alone does not establish the specific compute-output-adjusted formula.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.18Measures for Energy Conservation Review and Carbon-Emissions Evaluation of Fixed-Asset Investment Projects2 provisions / source records

2.2.18.1 Energy review and carbon evaluation as project gate

Internal source tag CN-R030

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Departmental rule
Issued
2025-07-17
Status at corpus cutoff
Current NDRC departmental rule; expressly replaced the 2023 Order No. 2 measures
Pinpoint
NDRC Order31 arts.2–3,8–10,13–14
Recorded legal proposition
A covered enterprise project may not start construction before a favorable energy-review opinion; an already-built noncompliant project may not operate.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: pinpoint actual threshold, scope and application articles rather than instructing readers to choose among arts.8–34.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.18.2 Change control, acceptance and enforcement

Internal source tag CN-R031

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Departmental rule
Issued
2025-07-17
Status at corpus cutoff
Current NDRC departmental rule; expressly replaced the 2023 Order No. 2 measures
Pinpoint
NDRC Order31 arts.18–19,21,23–26,28–34
Recorded legal proposition
Energy review continues through construction change, acceptance and operation; approval is not a one-time paper event.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: separated construction-stage amendment, two-year lapse and operational rectification.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.19Administrative Reconsideration Law of the People’s Republic of ChinaAdministrative reconsideration

Internal source tag CN-R033

Authority
National People’s Congress Standing Committee
Instrument
National law
Issued
2023-09-01
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Administrative Reconsideration Law arts. 1–3, 11–14, 20–30, 62–78
Recorded legal proposition
China provides a general administrative reconsideration route that may cover qualifying energy/permitting acts; it is not a bespoke electricity-market appeal.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.20Regulation on Emergency Response, Investigation and Handling of Electric Power Safety AccidentsElectric-power accident response

Internal source tag CN-R034

Authority
State Council
Instrument
Administrative regulation
Issued
2011-07-07
Status at corpus cutoff
Operative at the 2026-09-06 baseline and through 2026-12-31; superseded by the revised regulation on 2027-01-01
Pinpoint
State Council Order599 arts.5–6,12–15,18–19,37
Recorded legal proposition
Order No. 599 remained the operative administrative regulation on the baseline date.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: emergency-plan and restoration statements need arts.6,12–14, not only5,15,18–19.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.21Revised Regulation on Emergency Response, Investigation and Handling of Electric Power Safety AccidentsFuture emergency and accident regime

Internal source tag CN-R035

Authority
State Council
Instrument
Administrative regulation
Issued
2026-08-30
Status at corpus cutoff
Promulgated revised administrative regulation; future-effective and not operative at the baseline
Pinpoint
State Council Order No. 845 arts. 5-6, 8-15, 19-20, 25-26, 27-34, 38
Recorded legal proposition
Order No. 845 was promulgated on 2026-08-30 but expressly begins 2027-01-01.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.22Administrative Litigation Law of the People’s Republic of ChinaJudicial review of administrative action

Internal source tag CN-R036

Authority
National People’s Congress Standing Committee
Instrument
National law
Issued
2017-06-27
Status at corpus cutoff
Current
Pinpoint
Administrative Litigation Law arts. 1–6, 12–13, 44–49, 70–78
Recorded legal proposition
Administrative litigation supplies general judicial review for qualifying agency decisions but not every planning policy, grid dispatch act or private contract dispute.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.23Electricity Law of the People's Republic of ChinaService territory and duty to supply

Internal source tag CN-R101

Authority
National People's Congress Standing Committee
Instrument
National law
Issued
2018-12-29
Status at corpus cutoff
Current third-amended text
Pinpoint
Electricity Law arts.25–30, 64
Recorded legal proposition
China's statute states a direct service-area supply duty, but not an unconditional immediate energization right for any project size.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.24Regulation on Electricity Supply and UseCapacity-constrained service and connection readiness

Internal source tag CN-R102

Authority
State Council
Instrument
Administrative regulation
Issued
2019-03-02
Status at corpus cutoff
Current second-revision text in National Administrative Regulations Database
Pinpoint
Regulation arts.8–11, 20–24, 28, 32–35
Recorded legal proposition
Duty, capacity allocation, technical readiness, and contract are separate legal layers.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.25Rules on Electricity Supply Business3 provisions / source records

2.2.25.1 Application and readiness

Internal source tag CN-R103

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Departmental rule
Issued
2024-02-08
Status at corpus cutoff
Current; replaces 1996 Supply Business Rules under article 110
Pinpoint
Supply Business Rules arts.19–23; PDF pp.6–7
Recorded legal proposition
China uses document-, capacity-, and plan-validity gates rather than a single national MW-based queue threshold.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.25.2 Process timing and connection

Internal source tag CN-R104

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Departmental rule
Issued
2024-02-08
Status at corpus cutoff
Current; replaces 1996 Supply Business Rules under article 110
Pinpoint
Supply Business Rules arts.22–23, 47; PDF pp.6, 17–18
Recorded legal proposition
The instrument separates application response, supply-plan validity, inspection, and connection after pass.
Corpus review
P2: removed 'generally' from the mandatory three-working-day inspection cap while retaining prerequisites.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.25.3 Technical readiness and enforceability

Internal source tag CN-R105

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Departmental rule
Issued
2024-02-08
Status at corpus cutoff
Current; replaces 1996 Supply Business Rules under article 110
Pinpoint
Supply Business Rules arts.45,58–59,94–96,102,109–110
Recorded legal proposition
Technical compliance is a genuine access condition even without a large-load queue label.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.26Notice Improving Pricing Mechanisms to Promote Nearby Consumption of New-Energy GenerationResidual-grid pricing and cost causation

Internal source tag CN-R201

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission; National Energy Administration
Instrument
National administrative normative pricing policy
Issued
2025-09-09
Status at corpus cutoff
IN_FORCE
Pinpoint
Notice1192 I; II(1)–(3); III; IV
Recorded legal proposition
The 2025 pricing notice converts the beneficiary-pays principle into a concrete residual-grid charge architecture effective October 1, 2025.
Evidence limit
Provincial tariff inputs and project connection capacity determine the actual amount; the national formula is not itself a project bill.
Corpus review
P1: export spot settlement was incorrectly unconditional. Added the alternative two-part tariff and instrument-specific2030 scope; preserved loss/system/public-policy charge distinctions.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.27Notice issuing the Basic Rules for the Medium- and Long-Term Electricity MarketMedium- and long-term market access, contracts and green-power traceability

Internal source tag CN-R401

Authority
National Development and Reform Commission; National Energy Administration
Instrument
Joint departmental administrative normative document / national medium- and long-term electricity-market basic rules
Issued
2025-12-17
Status at corpus cutoff
Current at baseline; five-year term. Article98 repeals the 2020 basic rules and the 2024 green-electricity-trading special chapter.
Pinpoint
Basic Rules arts.10–12,45,47,51–55,64–68,98
Recorded legal proposition
Current national rules govern medium- and long-term market participation, transaction constraints, green-traceability contracts and emergency dispatch; they repeal the earlier 2020 basic rules and 2024 green-electricity special chapter on March1,2026.
Evidence limit
No project-specific data-center contract, trader qualification decision, quantity limit or operational outcome is established.
Corpus review
QA-CN current-rule repair; exact legal propositions independently checked in the archived official HTML.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.2.28NEW2026 National Green Computing Facilities Recommendation Notice (工信厅联节函〔2026〕433号)Ministerial and agency recommendation notice

How does a voluntary green-computing recommendation mechanism use operating data to shape facility standards and incentives?

Internal source tag CN-R501

Issued / announced
2026-09-21
Evidence status
ISSUED · 2026 application/recommendation cycle; NOT a universal mandatory facility standard
Issuing bodies
MIIT, NDRC, National Financial Regulatory Administration, Government Offices Administration and NEA offices
Document number
工信厅联节函〔2026〕433号 · dated 2026-09-08, published 2026-09-21
Eligibility
Facilities must have been stably operating as complete systems for more than one year, with independent power/cooling and clear boundaries
Assessment
Efficiency, carbon and water indicators; renewable-electricity share; rack/resource utilization, subject to attached evaluation criteria
Deadline
Recommendation submissions due 2026-11-16
Legal classification
Administrative application/recommendation and dynamic list management; do not equate list thresholds with mandatory operating rules

Source record: approved research update · 2026-10-19 · primary/official source; original 2026-09 Excel corpus preserved

2.3 National — policy instruments

2.3.1State Council General Office Notice on Standardizing Urban Utility ChargesConnection-cost boundary

Internal source tag CN-R106

Authority
State Council General Office; NDRC and other departments
Instrument
State Council General Office normative policy approving interdepartmental opinion
Issued
2020-12-23
Status at corpus cutoff
Current policy framework; local implementation determines detailed funding boundaries
Pinpoint
Opinion §II(2), §III(5), implementation from 2021-03-01
Recorded legal proposition
Cost allocation is boundary- and scope-specific, not simply 'utility pays all connection costs.'
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.4 Provincial & local — Beijing

2.4.1Beijing Provisions on Strengthening Energy Review of Data-Center Projects3 provisions / source records

2.4.1.1 Local data-center energy review and PUE

Internal source tag CN-R032

Authority
Beijing Municipal Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Local administrative normative rule
Issued
2023-07-03
Status at corpus cutoff
Current according to official source
Pinpoint
Beijing Provisions arts.2,5,7,10,14–15
Recorded legal proposition
Beijing links project energy review to energy-scaled PUE ceilings, renewable planning/verification, monitoring and differential operating electricity prices. The2023 rule cites a now-replaced national Order2; current national Order31 must be read alongside it.
Evidence limit
Implementation outcomes are not established by legal text alone.
Corpus review
P2: preserve original ambiguous progression units and exclude existing-grid renewable share; distinguish entry scope from art.7 new/expanded PUE scope.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.4.1.2 Project maturity, demand evidence and utilization discipline

Internal source tag CN-R038

Authority
Beijing Municipal Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Local administrative normative rule
Issued
2023-07-03
Status at corpus cutoff
Current according to official source
Pinpoint
Beijing Provisions arts.3–4,11–12
Recorded legal proposition
Beijing uses demand evidence, ownership-linked unstarted-project screening and a utilization-triggered change application. These are concrete administrative demand-credibility controls, not merely national planning aspirations.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.4.1.3 Cooling-water and resource-management conditions

Internal source tag CN-R039

Authority
Beijing Municipal Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Local administrative normative rule
Issued
2023-07-03
Status at corpus cutoff
Current according to official source
Pinpoint
Beijing Provisions arts.8–10
Recorded legal proposition
Beijing data-center energy-review provisions include express reclaimed-water and water-management conditions; they do not themselves issue a water-abstraction permit.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.5 Provincial & local — Beijing / Beijing Economic-Technological Development Area (Yizhuang New Town)

2.5.1Notice issuing Measures to Promote Green, High-Quality Development of Data Centers in the Beijing Economic-Technological Development AreaLocal project gating, economic-development agreements and energy-use limits

Internal source tag CN-R402

Authority
Beijing Economic-Technological Development Area Management Committee
Instrument
Local administrative normative measure
Issued
2024-03-13
Status at corpus cutoff
Official local page identifies the measure as valid at baseline
Pinpoint
Measures I (scope); II(8)–(10); final provision
Recorded legal proposition
The local measure combines a presumptive no-new-project position with a narrowly described agreement pathway, energy-use ceiling and compliance review. It is local and does not establish an executed contract or a general Chinese nationwide rule.
Evidence limit
No project-specific agreement, breach clause, enforcement decision or evidence of actual collection is publicly established here.
Corpus review
QA-CN counterexample repair from a complete current official local measure.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.6 Provincial & local — Fujian / Fuzhou

2.6.1Fuzhou public-complaint transfer and inspected-entity disposition table, Batch 152 provisions / source records

2.6.1.1 Operational noise and backup-generator smoke

Internal source tag CN-R303

Authority
Fuzhou Municipal Ecology and Environment Bureau / inspection-response authorities
Instrument
Official environmental-inspection complaint disposition record
Issued
2026-08-06
Status at corpus cutoff
Completed official investigation and corrective-direction record
Pinpoint
Table row 4
Recorded legal proposition
The official table reports that the Unicom machine-room air-conditioning and old backup diesel affected nearby residents and that the ecology/environment bureau required further air-conditioning noise reduction by2026-09-30. The table is site-specific implementation evidence, not proof of a quantified noise-limit breach or completed remediation.
Corpus review
P2 source classification: an official inspection-disposition table reports institutional findings/actions; the underlying individual corrective order or monitoring report is not archived. RC TierB institutional implementation evidence, not an autonomous statutory rule.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.6.1.2 Construction noise and dust

Internal source tag CN-R304

Authority
Fuzhou Municipal Ecology and Environment Bureau / inspection-response authorities
Instrument
Official environmental-inspection complaint disposition record
Issued
2026-08-06
Status at corpus cutoff
Completed official investigation and corrective-direction record
Pinpoint
Table row 7
Recorded legal proposition
The authority substantiated dust-control defects but rejected the claimed noise violation on monitoring and work-hour evidence.
Corpus review
P2 source classification: an official inspection-disposition table reports institutional findings/actions; the underlying individual corrective order or monitoring report is not archived. RC TierB institutional implementation evidence, not an autonomous statutory rule.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.7 Provincial & local — Guizhou / Gui'an New Area

2.7.1Acceptance notice for the EIA report form for the Gui'an Huawei Cloud Data Center AZ3 Machang Area Phase I 220 kV substation project (nuclear and radiation)Project environmental-acceptance documentary lead

Internal source tag CN-R302

Authority
Guizhou Provincial Department of Ecology and Environment
Instrument
UNRESOLVED project-page documentary lead; not substantive authority for reliance.
Issued
2025-03-03
Status at corpus cutoff
UNRESOLVED — earlier researcher snapshot was not independently re-opened through its canonical official URL during QA.
Pinpoint
Official-index retrieval note only; underlying notice could not be independently re-opened during QA.
Recorded legal proposition
No technical condition, approval effect, permit term or implementation outcome from this underlying notice is independently verified.
Evidence limit
Underlying official page, text and legal effect remain unavailable to QA; do not rely on prior extracted technical detail.
Corpus review
QA-CN exclusion: inaccessible snapshot is not treated as primary evidence.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.8 Provincial & local — Nanjing, Jiangsu

2.8.1Nanjing Operating Measures for Government-Enterprise Shared Electricity Connection WorksLocal connection-cost allocation and readiness timing

Internal source tag CN-R107

Authority
Nanjing Municipal Development and Reform Commission and other municipal authorities
Instrument
Municipal administrative normative measure
Issued
2025-08-25
Status at corpus cutoff
Current; supersedes the 2022 trial local approach
Pinpoint
Nanjing Measures arts.2–3,5,7,10–12,19,21–22
Recorded legal proposition
A local rule operationalizes national boundary policy through split electrical/civil funding and a one-month source-plan step.
Corpus review
P2 omission/counterevidence: do not contrast all China planning controls with US contractual demand credibility as if Chinese contracts are absent.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.9 Provincial & local — Ningxia / Zhongwei / Shapotou District

2.9.1Public notice of social-stability risk assessment for the 330 kV substation and export line of the Datang Zhongwei Cloud Base Data Center green-power supply 500 MW wind projectTransmission/green-supply project procedure

Internal source tag CN-R305

Authority
Shapotou District Development and Reform Bureau
Instrument
Project-specific social-stability-risk-assessment public notice
Issued
2026-03-24
Status at corpus cutoff
Official public-participation notice for associated generation/transmission project
Pinpoint
Project overview; risk-scope and five-working-day input period
Recorded legal proposition
A data-center green-power arrangement generated project-specific social-stability review for its dedicated transmission facilities.
Corpus review
Second-pass QA checked record/source linkage, legal-status qualification and resolved comparative use. Limit the proposition to the cited pinpoint and stated evidence gap.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.10 Provincial & local — Shaanxi / Xixian New Area, Fengxi New City

2.10.1Public notice of proposed EIA approval decision for ICBC Xi'an Data Center Xixian Campus Project (Phase I)Project EIA documentary lead

Internal source tag CN-R301

Authority
Fengxi New City Ecology and Environment working department
Instrument
UNRESOLVED project-page documentary lead; not substantive authority for reliance.
Issued
2026-05-21
Status at corpus cutoff
UNRESOLVED — earlier researcher snapshot was not independently re-opened through its canonical official URL during QA.
Pinpoint
Official-index retrieval note only; underlying notice could not be independently re-opened during QA.
Recorded legal proposition
No technical condition, approval effect, permit term or implementation outcome from this underlying notice is independently verified.
Evidence limit
Underlying official page, text and legal effect remain unavailable to QA; do not rely on prior extracted technical detail.
Corpus review
QA-CN exclusion: inaccessible snapshot is not treated as primary evidence.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.10.2Public notice of production-construction-project water-and-soil-conservation plan approval results, July 2026Water-and-soil-conservation documentary lead

Internal source tag CN-R308

Authority
Shaanxi Xixian New Area Fengxi New City Management Committee / Fengxi Government Service Center
Instrument
UNRESOLVED project-page documentary lead; not substantive authority for reliance.
Issued
2026-07-31
Status at corpus cutoff
UNRESOLVED — earlier researcher snapshot was not independently re-opened through its canonical official URL during QA.
Pinpoint
Official-index retrieval note only; underlying notice could not be independently re-opened during QA.
Recorded legal proposition
No technical condition, approval effect, permit term or implementation outcome from this underlying notice is independently verified.
Evidence limit
Underlying official page, text and legal effect remain unavailable to QA; do not rely on prior extracted technical detail.
Corpus review
QA-CN exclusion: inaccessible snapshot is not treated as primary evidence.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.11 Provincial & local — Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region

2.11.1Xinjiang's first multi-user green-power direct-connection projects announcedImplementation outcome / counterexample search

Internal source tag CN-R203

Authority
Xinjiang Development and Reform Commission
Instrument
Official provincial implementation/status report; not a legal instrument
Issued
2026-05-22
Status at corpus cutoff
CURRENT status report at cutoff
Pinpoint
Official Xinjiang DRC release dated 2026-05-22
Recorded legal proposition
The official Xinjiang DRC release reports two multi-user direct-power projects for data-center loads. The existence of that report is verified; construction and operational performance are not independently verified.
Evidence limit
The release reports projects as having landed and gives projections; it does not establish completed construction, actual generation, achieved hourly matching or commercial success.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.12 Provincial & local — Yunnan Province

2.12.1Notice issuing Yunnan's Implementation Plan for Promoting Green-Power Direct-Connection ConstructionProvincial implementation and project exit

Internal source tag CN-R202

Authority
Yunnan Provincial Development and Reform Commission; Department of Industry and Information Technology; Yunnan Provincial Energy Administration
Instrument
Provincial administrative implementation document
Issued
2025-07-08
Recorded legal proposition
Yunnan operationalizes the national invitation for provincial screening and exit mechanisms through local/project review, listing and post-entry assessment. It does not establish a universal private exit-damages formula.
Evidence limit
Its pre-October 2025 pricing language must be read with the later national 1192 pricing notice; listed or reviewed status is not proof of construction or performance.
Corpus review
P1/P2: exact title, at-least5workingdays, collection-substation distance, firm20%exportcap and national-versus-provincial exit distinction corrected.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

2.13 Provincial & local — Zhengzhou, Henan

2.13.1Zhengzhou Implementing Rules for Electricity Connection Works (Trial)Local connection-cost allocation and counterexamples

Internal source tag CN-R108

Authority
Zhengzhou Municipal Development and Reform Commission and other municipal authorities
Instrument
Municipal administrative normative measure
Issued
2022-03-18
Status at corpus cutoff
Still invoked by Zhengzhou authorities in official 2026 response; no superseding instrument located by 2026-09-06
Pinpoint
Zhengzhou Rules arts.2–4,6–12,20,23,25–26; official2026response confirms continuing invocation
Recorded legal proposition
Local variation and explicit exclusions defeat any inference of uniform user-free connection costs throughout mainland China.
Corpus review
P2 omission: preserved explicit local contractual breach arrangements and conditional construction timing; article26 provides one-year trial with continued execution absent objections.

Corpus reference: CR01_LAW_DATABASE(1).xlsx · 01_LAW_RECORDS

Follow the forces
behind AI.

A considered note on the infrastructure that makes intelligence possible. A research summary every other Wednesday, after editorial review.

One argument. Three developments worth reading. New research, original documents and corrections—with the evidence attached.

RSS / Email ↗Leave your email to receive the reviewed summary. Prefer a feed reader? The RSS feed is available on the subscription page.

A conversation in the margins.

0 / 500 characters

Comments are visible to readers of this site. Please keep your message within 500 characters.